A very enjoyable night it was, with the help of Rod Stewart who I remember as a wayward Scottish rockstar and football fan, but who now tops the charts with the Great American Songbook. My point about Katherine McPhee I think was proven beyond any doubt, she absolutely nailed "Someone to Watch Over Me". Together with Chris Daughtrey and Paris Bennett she will most likely make it to the final three and deservedly so. Loser tonight was Kellie Pickler who I think has reached the outer limits of her singing abilities. But the Albemarle blonde is not untalented, look out for her as a comedy or soap actress.